With no police report in which the officers assign fault to a party or footage that documents how the accident occurred, these claims can become extremely challenging to solve.
In such complex scenarios, the legal counsel of an experienced Houston car crash lawyer is crucial to effectively navigate the murky waters of fault and liability.
This expertise proves indispensable in unraveling the complexities of your ‘He Said, She Said’ car accident case, ensuring your narrative is clearly presented and defended.
You’ll benefit from the resources your attorney has when it comes to investigation. These resources can help you determine the at-fault party and have the capability to convert the findings into a strong liability and case.
Want your case to be successful? You’ll need to rely on a blend of three key factors, including:
- Physical evidence
- Credibility of each party
- Neutral witness statements
Read further to discover more.
Physical Evidence: What Does it Show?
Real evidence is what people can see, touch, or observe at the car accident scene. This is more concentrated than what witnesses describe. In a car accident, this type of evidence includes the automobiles involved and the scene itself. It is, in most cases, documented in videos and images.
When the real evidence clearly points to the at-fault driver, it doesn’t matter what the other party says about the occurrence. The judge is more likely to decide on the car accident case depending on what the real evidence indicates.
When the real evidence favors the claimant, the defense lawyer will advise the respondent to make a just settlement offer. Does the real evidence favor the defendant?
The claimant’s Houston car accident lawyer will have a mountain to climb with the plaintiff, explaining why it is time to take the modest offer and proceed with life.
Neutral Witnesses
In any car accident case, the judge deeply understands that the defendant and plaintiff are usually inherently biased, mainly due to their stake in the outcome. That’s when neutral witnesses come in. These individuals don’t have any stake in the outcome.
If the other party testifies that the incident was your fault, but three disinterested witnesses support your events’ version, you’ll elevate your chances of establishing a robust case.
It’s important to correctly capture the phone numbers, addresses, and names of any individual who might have witnessed all or part of the car accident. Surveillance footage or video clips from a dashboard camera can also provide real evidence.
Credibility of Each Party
Credibility equals believability. Does the at-fault driver blame you for the incident but does not seem to be credible? The judge probably will not accept the driver’s narration. But what makes an individual credible? When evaluating credibility, juries find solutions to these questions:
- Does the individual have a criminal record?
- Was the individual’s testimony at trial inconsistent or consistent?
- Does the individual’s version of events appear plausible?
- Does the individual have any reason to alter something?
- How did the individual speak, act, and look when talking about the car accident?
- How well did the individual sense, hear, and see what occurred?
- How well did the individual describe and remember the incident?
Want to win your “He Said, She Said” car accident case? The best way to achieve this effortlessly is to partner with a knowledgeable Houston car accident lawyer.